The dust has settled from your car accident, but the paperwork storm is just beginning. You open an email or a letter from the insurance adjuster, and there it is: the settlement number. Your heart sinks. It’s barely enough to cover your repairs, let alone your medical bills or lost wages. You feel insulted, maybe even panicked. You wonder, “Do I have to accept this? And if I say no, do I lose everything?”
This is a pivotal moment in your recovery process. The fear that saying “no” will make the money disappear is common, but unfounded.
In this guide, we will demystify the negotiation process. We will answer the critical question of what happens when you reject a car insurance settlement offer, explain why that first number is often just a starting point, and empower you to fight for the compensation you deserve.
You may also like: What Insurance Companies Will Backdate Car Insurance
The First Offer: It’s Not a Take-It-or-Leave-It Deal
To understand what happens when you say no, you first need to understand the nature of that initial check. Many drivers ask, “should I accept first offer from insurance company for car?” In most cases involving significant damage or injury, the answer is no.
Insurance companies are businesses. Their primary goal is to close claims quickly and for the lowest possible amount. That first settlement offer car accident victims receive is often calculated using algorithms or standardized software that may not account for the nuances of your pain, suffering, or specific vehicle condition.
When an adjuster sends that first number, they are rarely presenting their final limit. They are testing the waters. They want to see if you are desperate for cash or unaware of the true value of your claim.
Why Is the First Settlement Offer So Low?
If you feel the car insurance settlement offer is too low, you are likely right. Adjusters often start low because it leaves them room to move up during negotiations. If they started with their best offer, they would have no leverage. Common reasons for a lowball offer include:
Subjectivity: Pain and suffering damages are subjective, and insurers will always estimate these on the lower end initially.
Missing Documentation: They may not have all your medical records or repair estimates.
Depreciation Tactics: They might be undervaluing your vehicle’s pre-accident condition.
What Happens When You Reject a Car Insurance Settlement Offer?
So, you’ve decided the number on the table isn’t fair. You take a deep breath and tell the adjuster “no.” What happens next? Does the offer vanish? Do they close your file?
Here is the reality: When you reject a settlement offer, the negotiation process formally begins. The claim does not disappear. Instead, you enter a new phase of the insurance claim settlement process called “negotiation.”
Rejecting an offer signals to the insurance company that you know the value of your claim and are willing to fight for it. It forces the adjuster to re-evaluate their position.
The Immediate Aftermath of Rejection
Once you reject the offer:
- The Original Offer is Off the Table: Legally, a rejection voids the current offer. You cannot reject it today and then decide to accept that exact same offer next week without the insurer re-extending it. However, insurers will almost always keep that amount available as a “floor” for negotiations.
- You Must Provide a Counteroffer: You cannot simply say “no.” You must say, “No, because my damages are actually $X.” This keeps the dialogue moving.
- The Adjuster Reviews Your Case: They will look at the evidence you provide in your counteroffer to see if they missed something or if their initial calculation was flawed.
How to Reject an Insurance Settlement Offer
Knowing how to reject an insurance settlement offer properly is just as important as the decision itself. You should never do this in anger or over the phone without following up in writing.
Step 1: Analyze the Offer
Before you reject, review the offer line-by-line. Identify exactly where the discrepancy lies. Is the medical coverage too low? Did they miss the cost of a rental car?
Step 2: Formalize Your Rejection
You should send a formal demand letter or a response letter. This documents your rejection and outlines your reasoning.
- Be Professional: Keep emotions out of it.
- Be Specific: State clearly, “I am rejecting your settlement offer of $X.”
- Provide Evidence: Attach receipts, medical bills, and repair quotes that justify why the offer is insufficient.
Step 3: Make a Counteroffer
This is how you negotiate insurance settlement effectively. Your counteroffer should be higher than what you are actually willing to settle for, giving you room to compromise. For example, if you want $15,000 and they offered $10,000, you might counter with $20,000.
The Negotiation Dance: First vs. Second Settlement Offers
After you submit your rejection and counteroffer, the adjuster will likely come back with a second settlement offer car accident victims often find more reasonable.
How Many Offers Do Insurance Companies Make?
There is no hard rule on how many offers do insurance companies make. It depends on the gap between your numbers.
- Round 1: Lowball offer.
- Round 2: A moderate increase after you provide evidence.
- Round 3+: Smaller incremental moves as you get closer to a final number.
This back-and-forth continues until you reach an agreement or hit an impasse.
How Many Times Can You Reject a Settlement Offer?
You might be wondering, “how many times can you reject a settlement offer?” Theoretically, you can reject as many offers as you like until the statute of limitations (the legal deadline to file a lawsuit) runs out.
However, practical limits exist. If you reject reasonable offers repeatedly without new evidence, the adjuster may eventually say, “This is our final offer.” At that point, you have to decide whether to accept, arbitrate, or sue.
Strategies to Maximize Insurance Claim Payout
If you are not happy with the settlement offer, your goal is to bridge the gap between their low number and your actual needs. Here is how to maximize insurance claim payout during the rejection phase.
1. Document Everything
The adjuster needs proof to authorize a higher check. If you claim pain and suffering, provide a journal of your daily struggles. If you claim lost wages, provide pay stubs.
2. Use “Anchor” Numbers
Your initial demand letter sets the ceiling for the negotiation. If you start too low, you cap your potential payout. Start high (reasonably) to “anchor” the negotiation in a higher range.
3. Highlight Future Costs
Don’t just look at today’s bills. If your doctor says you might need physical therapy for a year, those future costs must be included in the settlement. Once you sign a release, you cannot come back for more money later.
4. Be Patient
Adjusters know that financial pressure makes people settle for less. If you can afford to wait, do not rush. Time is often on the side of the negotiator who is willing to wait for the right number.
Can You Reject a Total Loss Offer?
A specific and common scenario is when your car is declared a total loss. Drivers often panic, thinking the insurer’s valuation of their car is non-negotiable.
Can you reject a total loss offer? Absolutely.
Insurers use third-party vendors to determine the Actual Cash Value (ACV) of your vehicle. These reports can be flawed. They might miss upgraded features on your car, or compare your vehicle to others in worse condition.
If you reject a total loss offer, you must provide “comps”—comparable vehicles for sale in your area that show a higher market value than what the adjuster offered.
What If You Are Still Not Happy With Settlement Offer?
Sometimes, despite your best efforts to negotiate insurance settlement terms, the adjuster won’t budge, and you are still not happy with the settlement. If negotiations stall, you have options beyond just giving up.
Speak to a Supervisor
Adjusters have settlement authority limits. They might agree with you but simply lack the power to cut a larger check. Asking to speak to a manager can sometimes unlock higher tiers of authority.
Mediation or Arbitration
Many policies have clauses for alternative dispute resolution. A neutral third party can review the case and help facilitate a number that works for both sides.
Hiring an Attorney
If the insurer is acting in bad faith or the offer is egregiously low, hiring a personal injury attorney can change the dynamic immediately. Insurers often take attorney-represented claims more seriously because the threat of a lawsuit becomes real.
Filing a Lawsuit
This is the nuclear option. If you reject the final offer and cannot reach a resolution, you can file a lawsuit. However, this is time-consuming and expensive. Often, just filing the suit is enough to get the insurance company to reopen negotiations and offer a better settlement to avoid court costs.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I reject a total loss offer?
Yes, you can. If you believe the insurance company has undervalued your vehicle’s Actual Cash Value (ACV), you can reject the offer. You will need to provide evidence, such as recent sales listings of comparable vehicles in your area, to prove your car was worth more than their valuation.
How many times can I reject a settlement offer?
You can reject offers as many times as necessary, provided you are negotiating in good faith. However, if you reject a reasonable offer that covers all your documented expenses, the insurer may refuse to negotiate further. Eventually, you will reach a “final offer” stage where you must accept or pursue legal action.
What happens if I ignore an insurance claim?
Ignoring a claim will not make the offer go up. In fact, it can hurt you. Most states have a statute of limitations for injury and property damage claims. If you ignore the claim for too long, the statute may expire, and you will be barred from receiving any compensation at all. Additionally, the insurer may simply close your file administratively.
When should I accept a car insurance settlement offer?
You should accept an offer only when it fully covers your medical bills (past and future), lost wages, vehicle repair or replacement costs, and adequately compensates you for pain and suffering. Never accept an offer until your doctor confirms you have reached “maximum medical improvement” so you know the full extent of your injuries.
Do I have to accept the insurance adjuster’s offer?
No. An adjuster’s offer is simply a proposal. You are under no legal obligation to accept it. You have the right to review it, consult with professionals, and negotiate for a fairer amount.
Conclusion
Hearing a low number from an adjuster can be disheartening, but remember: it’s just business. Knowing what happens when you reject a car insurance settlement offer turns that moment of frustration into an opportunity. You are not powerless. By rejecting a low offer, providing solid evidence, and negotiating with patience, you significantly increase your chances of securing a fair payout.
Don’t settle for less than you deserve. Take the time to evaluate your damages, stand your ground, and use the rejection process to your advantage.